News, music, movies & restaurants from the editors of the Silicon Valley's #1 weekly newspaper.
Serving San Jose, Palo Alto, Los Gatos, Campbell, Sunnyvale, Mountain View, Fremont & nearby cities.

News and Features

home | metro santa cruz index | features | santa cruz | feature story

Original sin: Why listen to second-generation or film versions of these greats when you can hear the Broadway originals?

Give the Gift of Broadway

Those cheesy, over-the-top original cast soundtracks can't be beat.

By David Templeton

About halfway through the classic hooker fantasy Pretty Woman, the dentally gifted prostitute played by Julia Roberts casually informs the angsty billionaire played by Richard Gere that she has never seen an opera live onstage. In response, he cancels his many appointments, charters a jet and flies her to San Francisco to see La Traviata. While I, too, fantasize that someone would set me up with airfare and tickets to a really great concert or the latest hot Broadway musical—on the actual street named Broadway—I realize that I hold as much chance of that happening as the average guy has of finding someone like Julia Roberts working Hollywood Boulevard. Except for the rare trip to New York, the original cast recording is about as close as the average fan of Broadway musicals will get to the Great White Way. While it's not quite the same as being dazzled by a live show in all its visual splendor, a nice new original cast CD of Mel Brooks' Young Frankenstein: the Musical or Disney's brand-new stage version of The Little Mermaid have one advantage over the actual shows: they will probably last longer than two hours, and are there for replaying whenever you have the urge.

As it stands, Young Frankenstein, with a raunchy original score that satirizes Broadway while doing homage to the classic horror-spoof comedy, and The Little Mermaid, with mounds of new songs by the movie's original song-writer Alan Mencken, are the two hottest original cast recording this season, and may already be gone from local record stores. If so, consider these lesser-known Broadway shows that pack a solid musical punch, whether you've seen the show or not.

Lovemusik, which had a short run on Broadway cut off by the recent stage-hands strike, is a dark and richly literate cast recording featuring the great Michael Cerveris and Donna Murphy as the German composer Kurt Weill and his complicated muse/wife Lotte Lenya. The music is all Kurt Weill turned on its ear and given a lush, eerie new sound as the songs are employed to tell the couple's rocky love story. It's first-rate stuff.

For those with less highfalutin' tastes, the raucous, high-spirited stage adaptation of the terrible Olivia Newton-John movie Xanadu is a certified Broadway miracle: a fun, completely kick-ass-great transformation of a truly bad flick. With disco-era dance tunes and very witty ballads by Electric Light Orchestra's Jeff Lynne (also the mastermind behind the Traveling Wilburys), this cast recording is a surprisingly hip good time that comes with just a taste of tacky tongue-in-cheekiness.

Some theater fans know that there's one thing you can get from a big Broadway show, either in New York or wherever the touring cast takes it, that you probably can't get when the show finally appears on the stage of your local community theater: merch. Fortunately, you don't have to go to New York to pick up some theater-world kitsch; you can log onto TheaterMania (, where you can order the shirts and hats and other stuff being sold in the lobbies of just about every show in New York, on Broadway and off. Know someone who'd love a purple T-shirt with The Wedding Singer's Broadway logo on it? Got a friend who loves Monty Python and would salivate over a Spamalot baseball cap featuring the Holy Grail, or someone who would look great in a Spring Awakening shirt proclaiming "The Bitch of Living"? The perfect gift is a few clicks and a UPS delivery away.

And of course, if there is anyone out there eager to fly a critic to New York to see Harold Pinter's The Homecoming, I can be reached at the office. ...

Send a letter to the editor about this story.