News, music, movies & restaurants from the editors of the Silicon Valley's #1 weekly newspaper.
Serving San Jose, Palo Alto, Los Gatos, Campbell, Sunnyvale, Mountain View, Fremont & nearby cities.


home | metro silicon valley index | movies | current reviews | cult leader

Cinematic Enemy Number One

'Salo' returns to DVD

By Steve Palopoli

IF A MOVIE'S notoriety can be judged by the number of people who talk about it without having seen it, then Salo is without a doubt the world's most notorious film. That's not completely a bad thing, as Pier Paolo Pasolino's final film is actually more fun to talk about than it is to watch—in other words, what Bret Easton Ellis' American Psycho was to literature, Salo is to motion pictures.

It's not Pasolini's best movie, but it is his most famous one. It's famous for being an adaptation of the Marquis de Sade's crazy-as-fuck novel 120 Days of Sodom. It's famous for taking the basic setup of that novel—four powerful men lock themselves in a fortress with a small army of young captives in order to unleash their most sadistic fantasies— and setting it in the last days of Mussolini's Italy. It's famous for dividing up its story into a bastardization of Dante's Inferno: the "Antechamber of Hell," the "Circle of Obsessions," the "Circle of Shit" and the "Circle of Blood." It's famous for living up to all of those circles with scenes of torture, rape, mutilation, and lots and lots of poop. Most of all, though, it's famous for being nearly impossible to see. Banned in several countries and the center of an obscenity case in the United States in 1994 (which was dismissed), the film is rarely screened, though it got a rare showing a few months ago at San Francisco's Yerba Buena theater. It became the most-sought-after DVD in history, fetching $600 a copy and up on eBay, after the Criterion Collection released it in 1998 and then withdrew it because of licensing issues. The company showed some serious follow-through, though, and now has released a new edition that won't be going anywhere soon, it appears.

The funny thing is that the movie's notoriety has very little to do with the movie itself. What really lofted it into cult-legend status was its inclusion in an article called "Disturbo 13: The Most Disturbing Horror Films Ever Made" by Stanley Wiater. I first discovered the article when it came out in a book called Cut! Horror Writers on Horror Film back in 1992. Reference books to extreme cinema weren't easy to find then, there was no Internet, and the golden years of everything ever released coming out on DVD were still years away, so I used Wiater's list as a handy reference guide. For the most part, his picks for disturbing films were everything he made them out to be.

Recently, I discovered I'm not the only geek Wiater left a mark on. The "Disturbo 13" list has become a part of Internet lore—just Google it and see what you get. Some fans have even taken it upon themselves to update the list, fair enough since it's over 15 years old. Salo, however, remains on almost every Disturbo 13 list I could find. The legendary ookiness of this movie has taken root in film history, and it's not going anywhere. But I hope the release of the DVD gives more people (those who can stomach it, anyway) the chance to see it, and talk about it as a film rather than as a phenomenon.

For one thing, the new DVD should alleviate questions about the washed-out nature of the bootlegs that circulated for years—it looks vivid and striking once again. With the film's many stark tableaux and its brutal misanthropy, Pasolini appears to have been far more influenced by Luis Bu˝uel than by the marquis (though both de Sade and Bu˝uel had a lot more fun with their material). Like Ellis' novel, it's more interested in the boring emptiness of its monsters than their gruesome exploits. Underneath its cold exterior Salo is an angry indictment of fascism, liberalism, consumerism, the modern world, the bourgeoisie and humanity in general.

What's most shocking of all in terms of Pasolini's work is that he could have made a film as ugly, cynical and bleak as Salo just three short years after finishing his "trilogy of life" with Canturbury Tales.

But getting to the meaning of Salo is no small feat, even after repeat viewings, when its reputation precedes it so completely. Most recently, it was picked as "The Most Controversial Film Ever Made" in a poll of Time Out! readers in 2006. Do you think they all saw it? Of course not. The shadow of Disturbo 13 is as long and dark as Pasolini's final vision.

Click Here to Talk About Movies at Metro's New Blog

Send a letter to the editor about this story.

Movie Finder

Silicon Valley | Santa Cruz County | Sonoma / Marin / Napa

New and upcoming film releases.

Browse all movie reviews.